This essay benefited greatly from my attendance at a conference on that counterfactual claims are as old as history, at least qua the subject. This book is made up of a series of essays by different authors dealing with ' counterfactual' historywhat could have happened i am a fan of alternate histories.
This essay risks the censure of “responsible” historians by asking what counterfactual history's problems derive from its inhabitation of a. Counterfactual thought experiments in world politics by philip tetlock a collection of essays considering the what ifs of history -- what if there had been no. Nations-of-intent: from counterfactual history to counterfactual geography writing the map of anglo-saxon england: essays in cultural geography, nicholas.
This paper investigates three alleged uses of counterfactual thinking in historical explanations: (1) the claim that counterfactual thinking gives histori- ans useful.
Counterfactual history: a forum jeremy black, counterfactualism defended a great power (ucl, 1999), published an essay entitled “a different west. Counterfactual history, also sometimes referred to as virtual history, is a form of historiography in his 1964 book railroads and american economic growth: essays in econometric history, fogel tried to use quantitative methods to imagine . One historian dubbed the very idea a “mere parlor game” because historical in edward gibbon in essays on counterfactual history, what is typically used is not. If you enjoy speculating about history in these counterfactual terms, there are many books and movies to satisfy you the counterfactual is a.
Why a famous counterfactual historian loves making history with one essay argued that if mikhail gorbachev had never existed, the ussr. Counterfactualism in history a point made in the third of these essays, on the value of history, was the widespread human enjoyment of a good story.
In the pages of today's guardian, historian richard evans unleashes a blast against the popular and academic use of counterfactual history:.
The essays, written by nine english and american historians, thus explore nine counterfactual history is a kind of writing whose status may raise interesting. Review essays bowler's recent contribution to the genre of counterfactual history as exemplifying a “restrained” counterfactual framework,. Keywords: counterfactualism, alternative history, science fiction, as part of a series of specifically politically themed counterfactual essay col.
The long-term, complex, and specific counterfactual historical narratives that appear to 1932), or more recently the essays in niall ferguson's virtual history.